Watch: Masterchef contestant speaks to BBC Newsnight about being edited out of new series
The BBC is facing mounting pressure to reconsider airing this year’s series of MasterChef, after presenters Gregg Wallace and John Torode were sacked.
The broadcast union Bectu said that bad behaviour “should not be rewarded with prime-time coverage”, while a leading women’s rights charity warned many people would feel “deeply uncomfortable” to see the show on their TV screens.
It came after a MasterChef contestant said she was edited out after asking for the new series not to be broadcast following claims against the two hosts.
The BBC previously said it had not been “an easy decision” to run the series, adding that there was “widespread support” among the chefs for it going ahead.
BBC/Shine TV
John Torode, left, and Gregg Wallace had presented MasterChef since 2005
The controversy over MasterChef started last year, when BBC News first revealed claims of misconduct against Gregg Wallace.
Last month, a report by the show’s production company revealed that more than 40 complaints against Wallace had been upheld, while a claim that Torode had used a severely offensive racist term was also substantiated.
Following the report, the BBC announced that the new series – filmed before Wallace and Torode were sacked – would still be shown on BBC One and iPlayer.
The corporation said it reached the decision after “careful consideration and consultation” with the contestants.
But speaking exclusively to BBC News, head of Bectu Philippa Childs called on the BBC “to reconsider its decision to broadcast the latest series of MasterChef”.
She said: “Whilst the BBC claims that it has consulted with contestants there appears to have been no consultation with complainants; freelancers who have taken the very difficult step of speaking out and who will legitimately feel distressed as the show appears on their screens several times a week over the next two months.”
Ms Childs added that freelancers whose complaints had been upheld would “undoubtedly be triggered” by the decision to air the series.
“If [the BBC] are serious about addressing this industry wide problem, broadcasters should not reward bad behaviour with prime-time coverage,” she said.
BBC News understands the new series may be re-edited in light of the findings, with the prominence of Wallace and Torode re-examined.
It is thought there will be limitations on how much the pair can be edited out, but the focus is likely to be on the contestants.
The BBC declined to comment on Ms Childs’ comments.
Her views were echoed by some of the women who came forward with claims against Wallace.
Reacting to the news that it would be aired, one former MasterChef worker who claimed Wallace groped her said the decision to broadcast the series showed “a blatant disregard for the people who have come forward”.
She warned it was “a total reversal of so-called firing from MasterChef – how can you be fired by your work is still made public?”
Another former MasterChef worker, who said Wallace pulled his trousers down in front of her, told BBC News the decision to air the series was “profoundly disrespectful” to people like her who had made allegations.
“It ultimately sends a message that such behaviour can be overlooked.”
She added that she had not been consulted over the decision to air the series.
Penny East, chief executive of the Fawcett Society, also expressed concern over the decision.
“Seeing Gregg Wallace on our screens will be deeply uncomfortable for many people, not least the brave women who have spoken about his appalling behaviour,” she said.
“It can’t be right that men who sexually harass women continue to be given platform and allowed to maintain their profile and power.”
Ms East added that it was a “difficult dilemma”, adding: “We also know that all of the contestants will have put their hearts and souls into the competition over the many weeks of filming. To leave them with nothing to show for this feels uncomfortable.
“Perhaps editing out the presenters entirely would have been a better solution.”
‘Ideally, it would’ve been axed’
On Thursday, one of the contestants on the new series of MasterChef said she was edited out after asking for it not to be broadcast.
Sarah Shafi told BBC Newsnight that “in an ideal world, what would have happened is that it would have been axed” out of respect to those people whose complaints had been upheld.
She said that would have sent “a strong message that [the BBC] are not supporting people in those prominent positions or facilitating some sort of enabling environment”.
Ms Shafi said that she had felt “pressurised into saying yes” to the show going ahead and the solution of editing her out left her “flabbergasted”.
“This is a woman being edited out. Again, the woman gets silenced into extinction. It’s happening time and time again.”
The BBC said MasterChef’s production company Banijay had consulted with all the contestants before the decision to run the series was made.
Both said they were “sorry” she did not support the decision to air it.
Separately, Ms Shafi also said that her experience on the show “wasn’t a good one” and that being on the show felt like “a boys’ game”.
“I went there being faithful to food, not to be eyed up and ogled, it just felt that was very uncomfortable for me,” she said. “That was with Gregg Wallace.”
Responding to those claims, Banijay said: “We have no record of Sarah raising concerns with producers at the time of filming, however when raised during the formal investigation process, we thoroughly assessed her claims including reviewing relevant programme rushes with Sarah.
“These do not support her version of events regarding inappropriate comments or actions by Gregg Wallace which Sarah has acknowledged.”
BBC News has also approached Gregg Wallace for comment.
‘Not an easy decision’
In announcing its decision to run the series, the BBC said: “This has not been an easy decision in the circumstances and we appreciate not everyone will agree with it.
“In showing the series, which was filmed last year, it in no way diminishes our view of the seriousness of the upheld findings against both presenters. We have been very clear on the standards of behaviour that we expect of those who work at the BBC or on shows made for the BBC.
“However, we believe that broadcasting this series is the right thing to do for these cooks who have given so much to the process. We want them to be properly recognised and give the audience the choice to watch the series.”
Former contestants on the show have also previously told BBC News that being on MasterChef can be “life-changing” for them.
The upheld claims against Wallace included one of unwelcome physical contact and another three of being in a state of undress.
A total of 83 complaints were made against Wallace, and he said he was cleared of “the most serious and sensational allegations”.
But he added: “I recognise that some of my humour and language, at times, was inappropriate.
“For that, I apologise without reservation. But I was never the caricature now being sold for clicks.”
The upheld complaint against Torode related to a severely offensive racist term allegedly used on the set of MasterChef in 2018.
The presenter said he had “no recollection” of it and that any racist language is “wholly unacceptable”.