Paul Seddon
Political reporter
Getty Images
The UK should immediately recognise the state of Palestine, a majority of MPs on the Commons foreign affairs committee have said.
It comes as Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer faces fresh calls from within Labour’s ranks to make the move, amid warnings of mass starvation in Gaza, and after France indicated it would be doing so within months.
In a new report, the Labour and Lib Dem MPs on the select committee argue that statehood is an “inalienable right” that should “not be made conditional”.
But their two Tory colleagues said a state of Palestine should only be recognised as part of a long-term political solution to the conflict in the Middle East, echoing the Labour government’s position.
French President Emmanuel Macron said on Thursday evening that his country would officially recognise a Palestinian state at a UN meeting in September.
Sir Keir has previously said the UK should reserve recognition of Palestinian statehood for when it would have the “greatest impact” – without specifying when this would be.
But in a report published on Friday, the committee said the government should make the move “while there is still a state to recognise”.
“An inalienable right should not be made conditional,” the report adds.
“The government cannot continue to wait for the perfect time because experience shows that there will never be a perfect time.”
That section of the report was backed by all six Labour MPs who voted, including chairwoman Dame Emily Thornberry, and the two Lib Dems on the committee.
It was not endorsed by its two Conservative members, Aphra Brandreth and Sir John Whittingdale, who said the UK should only back the move as part of a wider two-state solution to the Israel-Palestinian conflict.
It is not unusual for select committees to be split on controversial issues but they will normally try to speak with one voice.
The Tory MPs on the foreign affairs committee made an unsuccessful attempt to change the report to reflect their views, arguing that recognition should accompany the release of hostages taken by Hamas in October 2023, and the creation of Palestinian authorities without Hamas supporters.
Around 60 MPs reportedly called for the UK to immediately recognise Palestine in a letter earlier this month, with London major Sir Sadiq Khan also making the call on Wednesday.
In a statement on Thursday evening condemning “unspeakable and indefensible” conditions in Gaza, Sir Keir said statehood was an “inalienable right”.
He reiterated his call for a ceasefire in the conflict, adding this would “put us on a path” towards recognising a Palestinian state.
Business Secretary Jonathan Reynolds had earlier said Labour ministers were “deeply committed” to recognition, but they wanted it to be “meaningful,” adding: “At the minute, there is not a Palestinian state there”.
‘Not listening’
Most countries – about 139 in all – formally recognise a Palestinian state, although many European nations – and the United States – say they will only do so as part of moves towards a long-term resolution to the conflict.
Spain, Ireland and Norway formally took the step last year, hoping to exert diplomatic pressure to secure a ceasefire in Gaza.
Palestine currently has limited rights to participate in the work of the UN, and is also recognised by various international organisations, including the Arab League.
Sceptics argue recognition would largely be a symbolic gesture unless questions over the leadership and extent of a Palestine state are addressed first.
In their report, the MPs acknowledged that the Israeli government “is not listening to the UK,” and was only “sporadically” listening to the United States, by far its most significant military backer.
Speaking to the BBC on Tuesday, former UK Foreign Office boss Lord McDonald argued recognition itself “doesn’t really amount to very much,” adding that a Palestine state lacked defined borders or an “agreed government”.
Aid distribution call
The report comes after the UK and 27 other countries condemned the “drip feeding of aid and the inhumane killing of civilians” seeking food and water in Gaza.
Israel’s foreign ministry rejected the countries’ statement, saying it was “disconnected from reality and sends the wrong message to Hamas”.
In the rest of their report, which was endorsed unanimously, the MPs called for a UN-led system to distribute aid in Gaza, replacing the controversial US-backed Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF) in place since May.
They also said the UK should justify how “allowing indirect exports” of British parts for F-35 fighter jets used by Israel complies with the UK’s obligations under international law.
The UK says it does not export the parts directly to Israel, but rather to manufacturing centres abroad as part of a global programme, and it cannot prevent Israel from obtaining the components.